Northwind Starter Kit ReviewData Access review thoughts

time to read 3 min | 476 words

This is a review of the Northwind Starter Kit project, this review revision 94815 from Dec 18 2011.

In my last few posts, I have gone over the data access strategy used in NSK. I haven’t been impressed. In fact, I am somewhere between horrified, shocked and amused in the same way you feel when you see a clown slipping on a banana peel.  Why do I say that? Let us trace a single call from the front end all the way to the back.

The case in point, CatalogController.Product(id) action. This is something that should just display the product on the screen, so it should be fairly simple, right? Here is how it works when drawn as UML:


To simplify things, I decided to skip any method calls on the same objects (there are more than a few).

Let me show you how this looks like in actual code:


Digging deeper, we get:


We will deal with the first method call to CatalogServices now, which looks like:


I’ll skip going deeper, because this is just a layer of needless abstraction on top of Entity Framework and that is quite enough already.

Now let us deal with the second call to CatalogServices, which is actually more interesting:


Note the marked line? This is generating a query. This is interesting, because we have already loaded the product. There is no way of optimizing that, of course, because the architecture doesn’t let you.

Now, you need all of this just to show a single product on the screen. I mean, seriously.

You might have noticed some references to things like Read Model in the code. Which I find highly ironic. Read Models are about making the read side of things simple, not drowning the code in abstraction on top of abstraction on top of abstraction.

In my next post, I’ll show a better way to handle this scenario. A way that is actually simpler and make use an of actual read model and not infinite levels of indirection.

More posts in "Northwind Starter Kit Review" series:

  1. (26 Jan 2012) Conclusion
  2. (24 Jan 2012) That CQRS thing
  3. (23 Jan 2012) It is all about the services
  4. (20 Jan 2012) From start to finishing–tracing a request
  5. (18 Jan 2012) If you won’t respect the database, there will be pain
  6. (16 Jan 2012) Refactoring to an actual read model
  7. (13 Jan 2012) Data Access review thoughts
  8. (12 Jan 2012) The parents have eaten sour grapes, and the children’s teeth are set on edge
  9. (11 Jan 2012) Data Access and the essence of needless work, Part II
  10. (10 Jan 2012) Data Access and the essence of needless work, Part I