TFS, Zero Friction and living in an imperfect world
Roy responded to my post about disliking TFS:
I think that Oren is making one big mistake: he's throwing the baby out with the bath water. Just because the source control is not as zero-friction as some open source alternatives, does not mean that TFS is not a valuable suite of tools, with more added value than most open source tools that I know of.
[List of advantages that TFS has snipped, will cover them later]
I mean, Oren, c’mon! You don’t like a part of a part of team system – the source control aspect is not perfect for you, but what alternative do you have for a suite of tools that works together so powerfully?
First of all, I am grateful that I am only making one big mistake :-) That said, I don't really have an issue with the rest of TFS, but the problem is that without the source control integration, it is losing quite a bit of its charm. The source control is the most visible and annoying part of TFS, I would love to give it a short with SVN integration, but I don't really see it coming.
Roy goes on to list a few points, which I would get to cover:
Just about any bug tracker has this ability, it is not unique for TFS by eany means. Usually it is a matter of a few config options for SVN and a post-commit hook.
This is nice, but it won't work with anything other SCM, so that it not very good. I can get that with Trac as well, so that is not something that really bothers me.
Bug, not a feature. You can't move the folder around, you have cruft left over in your system, deleting the folder won't rid of the remains, etc. Beside, what is the problem with "MyProd\trunk", "MyProd\Branch-1.0", etc?
All of which are nice, but by no mean unique or even very impressive on their on.
Actually, no, I don't. And I flat out refuse to suffer the initial pain for the promised land. Feel free to call me heretic.
The promise of TFS is that you get everything integrated, in one package. The problem of TFS is that you get everything integrated, in one package. I actually like the work items, and if I could get it outside of VS (don't your dare make the IDE any slower), I would like it better. The problem is that I can get as much and more from freely available projects, that works in zero friction.
And you know what, I can get them to work together in the same time it takes to setup TFS.