Ayende @ Rahien

Refunds available at head office

MSDN vs. Google

Here is a small experiment, I want to read the documentation for IDispatchMessageInspector

Just to give an idea, here is the wget output for this address:

wget http://msdn2.microsoft.com/en-us/library/system.servicemodel.dispatcher.idispatchmessageinspector.aspx
--00:59:48--  http://msdn2.microsoft.com/en-us/library/system.servicemodel.dispatcher.idispatchmessageinspector.aspx
           => `system.servicemodel.dispatcher.idispatchmessageinspector.aspx'
Resolving msdn2.microsoft.com... 207.46.16.251
Connecting to msdn2.microsoft.com|207.46.16.251|:80... connected.
HTTP request sent, awaiting response... 200 OK
Length: 122,022 (119K) [text/html]

100%[========================================================>] 122,022        5.74K/s    ETA 00:00

01:00:12 (5.74 KB/s) - `system.servicemodel.dispatcher.idispatchmessageinspector.aspx' saved [122022/122022]

That is right, over a minute half a minute to download just the HTML content of a single page, over two minutes just to get the simplest page to load.

Let me contrast that with the comparable experience:

  • Go to google.com
    Load time: faster than I can measure
  • Put IDispatchMessageInspector and hit enter
    Load time: ~2 Seconds
  • Go to the first result's cached content
    Load time: ~7 seconds

You know what the real sad part is? The google approach is faster than locally installed MSDN!

Comments

Luke Breuer
04/24/2007 10:41 PM by
Luke Breuer

What are your computer's specs? I think local MSDN takes < 5 seconds from a cold start on mine: Raptor 10K 150GB, Core2 2.66GHz, 4GB DDR2.

I do agree that online MSDN is horribly slow, although not nearly as slow as you have noted. I'm guessing I'm a lot closer to the closest MSDN server than you are.

Grimace of Despair
04/25/2007 06:41 AM by
Grimace of Despair

At the local DevDays, I recently asked Ingo Rammer if he had any idea why the MSDN site has (always?) been so painfully slow, knowing it's MS window to developers. You might want to show to (potential) users that your technology works, don't you? He couldn't come up with anything either but "probably no priority".

For me, it's a big showstopper. I sometimes find myself not wading through MSDN just because I know I will be spending minutes on searching just a small feature. Long live Google cache!

Luke Breuer
04/25/2007 02:23 PM by
Luke Breuer

To be honest, I pity anyone not using a lightening fast machine with VS2005 or client MSDN. With a top-flight machine, VS2005 is pretty decent. Without... convert to Linux. :-p

Rachit
04/25/2007 06:40 PM by
Rachit

Sooo much agreed. MSDN2 is definitely dog slow. Especially, when it tries to load the left side navigational Tree. Takes forever... Google definitely returns better results.

mawi
04/29/2007 01:59 PM by
mawi

Right on!! I've thought the same thing!

A lot of people are missing the bit about google beating LOCAL MSDN search as well. Embarrasing to MS and freakin annoying to us devs.

Pavel Chuchuva
06/08/2007 12:55 AM by
Pavel Chuchuva

Google MSDN search:

http://www.google.com/coop/cse?cx=001706605492879182808%3Ayra97xpb_7y

Comments have been closed on this topic.