Ayende @ Rahien

My name is Oren Eini
Founder of Hibernating Rhinos LTD and RavenDB.
You can reach me by phone or email:


+972 52-548-6969

, @ Q c

Posts: 6,026 | Comments: 44,842

filter by tags archive

Domain Specific Language: Losing the original language

time to read 1 min | 183 words

Here is an interesting question, at what point you drive away so far from the original language that you lose the benefits of an internal DSL?

The following examples are several ways to represent the same thing, going from the extreme DSL to the no DSL to C#. I think that they all have value, and neither cross that line, but I believe that they will help make the point. The example here is a a simple MonoRail Controller:


controller Field:
    action Tag:
           @defaultTags = [ "green", "trees", "growth" ]


controller Field:
    def Tag():
         @defaultTags = [ "green", "trees", "growth" ]


controller Field:
    def Tag():
          PropertyBag["defaultTags"] = [ "green", "trees", "growth" ]


class FieldController(Controller):
   def Tag():
          PropertyBag["defaultTags"] = [ "green", "trees", "growth" ]


public class FieldController : Controller
	public void Tag()
		PropertyBag["defaultTags"] = new string[] { "green", "trees", "growth" };

Any comments?


Arne Claassen

I guess I'm not sure that i'd agree that driving an internal DSL away from the original language is a bad thing. For me i'd go with 1 or 5. The inbetween ones seem like they compromise the clarity of the DSL in order to fit better into the internal language, which lends confusion as to what is DSL and what is native syntax that can be used for other things.

Markus Zywitza

I disagree. All DSL grades can be useful, provided that it is possible to do something else than specifying property bags params with it.

The example above shows only the syntactic sugar, but the question is, how much logic support them. Any of #1 to #4 is completely useless if only a handful of commands are possible.

OTOH, if they allow the full power of boo, all of them are useful, no matter where you have to write def, action, class or controller.

I don't comment on MonoRail with C#. It simply works :-)

Ayende Rahien

All of them allows you to use boo, yes.

the question is if this adds value or does it subtract it? Does the desire to work in the terms of MVC subtract from the value in understand what the code does?

Comment preview

Comments have been closed on this topic.


No future posts left, oh my!


  1. Technical observations from my wife (3):
    13 Nov 2015 - Production issues
  2. Production postmortem (13):
    13 Nov 2015 - The case of the “it is slow on that machine (only)”
  3. Speaking (5):
    09 Nov 2015 - Community talk in Kiev, Ukraine–What does it take to be a good developer
  4. Find the bug (5):
    11 Sep 2015 - The concurrent memory buster
  5. Buffer allocation strategies (3):
    09 Sep 2015 - Bad usage patterns
View all series


Main feed Feed Stats
Comments feed   Comments Feed Stats